The extended mind argument against phenomenal intentionality
نویسندگان
چکیده
Abstract This paper offers a novel argument against the phenomenal intentionality thesis (or PIT for short). The argument, which I'll call extended mind intentionality, is centered around two claims: first asserts that some source intentional states extend into environment, while second maintains no conscious environment. If these claims are correct, then false, implies extension of predicated upon consciousness. important because it undermines an increasingly prominent account nature intentionality. has entered philosophical mainstream and now serious contender to naturalistic views like tracking theory functional role (Loar 1987, 2003; Searle 1990; Strawson 1994; Horgan Tienson 2002; Pitt 2004; Farkas 2008; Kriegel 2013; Montague 2016; Bordini 2017; Forrest Mendelovici 2018). challenges popular sentiment consciousness grounds
منابع مشابه
Phenomenal Intentionality Meets the Extended Mind
Introduction Over the last quarter of the twentieth century, an orthodoxy of sorts had gelled in the philosophy of mind around a kind of psychological externalism, the idea that some mental states individuate sensitively to extra-cranial factors. More recently, two trends of thought have departed from this young orthodoxy in opposite directions. On the one hand, a cluster of ideas captured in s...
متن کاملPhenomenal Intentionality Meets the Extended Mind, finalest
Introduction Over the last quarter of the twentieth century, an orthodoxy of sorts had gelled in the philosophy of mind around a kind of psychological externalism, the idea that some mental states individuate sensitively to extra-cranial factors. More recently, two trends of thought have departed from this young orthodoxy in opposite directions. On the one hand, a cluster of ideas captured in s...
متن کاملIntentional Inexistence and Phenomenal Intentionality
How come we can represent Bigfoot even though Bigfoot does not exist, given that representing something involves bearing a relation to it and we cannot bear relations to what does not exist? This is the problem of intentional inexistence. This paper develops a two-step solution to this problem, involving (first) an adverbial account of conscious representation, or phenomenal intentionality, and...
متن کاملPhenomenal intentionality past and present: introductory
A growing amount of research on intentionality within Anglo-American philosophy of mind has been focusing on the notion of phenomenal intentionality. How to characterize phenomenal intentionality is not a straightforward matter, but one relatively neutral option is in terms of counterfactual dependence: an intentional state has phenomenal intentionality just in case if it were not phenomenal it...
متن کاملNot What it’s Like but Where it’s Like: Phenomenal Consciousness, Sensory Substitution and the Extended Mind
According to the hypothesis of extended cognition (henceforth ExC), the machinery of mind sometimes extends beyond the skull and skin. To put things another way, the defining claim of ExC is that, contra the neuro-centrism of most modern cognitive science and most modern naturalistic philosophy of mind, the parts of the physical world that instantiate or implement cognitive states and processes...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
ژورنال
عنوان ژورنال: Phenomenology and The Cognitive Sciences
سال: 2021
ISSN: ['1572-8676', '1568-7759']
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11097-021-09765-8